Doctor's Orders VS One

Sonic74205 · **Fri Jun 15, 2007 12:51 pm Doctor's Orders VS One**

Alright guys its time for a good old fashioned poll!

Out of Enterprise's "Doctor's Orders" and Voyagers "One"

They are both basically the same episode. In the Voyager version Seven of Nine has to look after the ship and the comatose crew as they pass through a lethal region of space.
In the Enterprise version Doctor phlox has to look after the ship and the comatose crew as they pass through a lethal region of space.

Personally my favorite is Doctor's Orders. I love the fact that the situation fits the doctor perfectly seeing as he comes from a planet thats extremely crouded and very over populated, with billions of people all living on just one single continent. However the best part of this episode for me is T'Pol. She is pretty amazing as ever and i also love the twist at the end. Whats better yet is if you watch the episode a second time you actually see that the twist at the end is being set up and is clear throughout the whole episode. In my opinion the writers really struck gold with this one!

Lt. Saavik · Lieutenant Joined: 21 Jun 2007 Posts: 196 Location: Europe

I'm quite torn, because both episodes are of a very high level, highlighting the qualities of the two characters involved and the way their actors portrayed them. As far as I'm concerned, I find more interesting the VOY episode, with 7 facing all her ancient fears and overcoming them. Phlox is a very good character, maybe the one I really like in ENT. The way he faces the situation he finds himself in, together with T'Pol, who couldn't be more different, is very clever. But my vote goes to "One".

squiggy · **Sun Jun 24, 2007 3:16 pm**

As I hate enterprise, this isn't even a contest for me.

Shawn Cordell · **Sun Jun 24, 2007 4:53 pm**

JupiterPrime · Lieutenant Joined: 13 Mar 2006 Posts: 208

While ENT's version of the episode was a blatant recycling of ideas, I at least liked that with Phlox's psychosis of the event, they showed a different type of perspective of his psyche, as opposed to 7/9's in his attempt to cope with the stress.

Kuro-chan · **Wed Jul 04, 2007 7:33 pm**

I have to go with "One" for the following:

Doctor's Orders required the writers to essentially lie to the audience about T'Pol's condition. Since Dr. Phlox put everyone in a coma to travel through the forming anamoly, he should have known that he put T'Pol out as well, and would not have expected her walking about the ship doing "nothing".

lifeguide · **Thu Nov 29, 2007 5:42 pm**

I liked both episodes but because I like Phlox more than Seven I will go for the Enterprise episode.

In "One", there are too many moments where Seven is by herself and the episode doesn't move anywhere.

Debra · Sweetest Angel Joined: 26 May 2007 Posts: 444

I am not going to even vote because I like Dr.
phlox and the doctor.

Blancie · **Fri Nov 30, 2007 12:45 pm**

I don't like anything Enterprise, I hate it. I think it's so...poor.

But One was a great episode! Gotta love Voyager.

5thhouse · **Sun Dec 02, 2007 12:55 pm**

I don't really like ENT in any way, so my vote goes for "one"

Omok · Lieutenant Joined: 28 Mar 2007 Posts: 170

7 of 9 vs Phlox?

Not much of a contest.

Blancie · **Sun Dec 02, 2007 9:04 pm**

Of course not.

7 of 9 everytime.